Blind review is a method employed to make sure that manuscripts are published with the highest quality. This method is fundamental to the objective review of research studies and is preferred by many scientific journals. Reviewer views are determinant in the publication quality of IJPE. All manuscripts submitted to IJPE are blind reviewed according to the following steps :
Blind Review Method
IJPE employs the double blind review method in the review process of all submitted manuscripts. In this method the identities of the authors and reviewers are confidential.
Initial Review Process
The studies submitted to IJPE are reviewed by the editors first. At this stage, the studies which are not related with the journal's aim and scope, weak in terms of language and wording, lack originality, contain critical scientific mistakes and do not meet the publishing criteria are rejected. The authors of such studies are informed about the decision within two months after the submission date. The studies deemed acceptable, on the other hand, are assigned to two reviewers related with the subject of the manuscript.
Reviewers are assigned according to the content of the studies and their field of expertise.
In general, the reviewers' reports are based on the originality of the studies, methods, ethical considerations, consistent presentation of the findings and results and analysis of the studies with respect to literature. This evaluation is done according to the following:
Reviewers are given 6 weeks for review. Reviewers may ask multiple editing of a study if they deem necessary.
The editor evaluates the reviewers' comments within 2 weeks at the latest and as a result of this evaluation the editor makes his/her final decision regarding the study.
Editorial Board Decision
The editor reports the decision to the author(s) in a week at the latest along with the suggestions made by the reviewers. In this process the studies that are not accepted for publication are returned without request for plagiarism detection. The final decision about the accepted studies is made based on the results of the plagiarism detection report.
How long does the Publication Review Process last?
It is anticipated that the publication review process of the studies submitted to IJPE be completed in 3-5 months. However, the period during which editors or reviewers ask the author(s) to do editing and the author(s) complete the editing is not included in this time frame.